OPEC yesterday agreed on a deepest-ever net cut of 2.2 million barrels per
day (bpd) as of January 1, bringing the total output cut in 2008 to 4.2 million
bpd, in another attempt to bolster sagging oil prices under the global economic
slowdown.
Yet analysts say it still costs the Organization of Petroleum Exporting
Countries (OPEC) several months and even further cuts to harvest at the level it
is craving for, ruling out the possibility of a quick fix in the volatile
market.
OUTPUT SLASH WITHOUT SURPRISE
The decision made at the oil cartel's 151st extraordinary meeting in
northwestern Algerian city of Oran came without surprise given the previous
slump and a succession of pro-cut announcements by oil powers.
Chakib Khelil, OPEC's current rotating president, and also Algerian Minister
of Energy and Mines, announced in Oran that the cartel "agreed to cut 4.2
million bpd from the actual September 2008 OPEC-11 production of 29.045 million
bpd, effective of Jan. 1,2009," in light of observing "crude volumes entering
the market remain well in excess of actual demand."
Over the past five months, oil prices have witnessed a steep slide in the
international markets after a record high of some US$147 per barrel in July 11.
After OPEC's announcement of cut on Wednesday, light, sweet crude for January
delivery dropped to the lowest in more than four years of some 40 dollars in the
New York Mercantile Exchange, while Brent North Sea crude for delivery in
January stood at some US$45 in London's Inter Continental Exchange, shedding
more than 60 percent from its zenith.
Khelil said on December 6 that OPEC, which pumps nearly 40 percent of world's
oil, is to cut its oil output in a "significant magnitude" in order to stem the
tumbling oil prices. He reiterated on Dec. 11 that the reduction in Oran would
be "severe."
OPEC Secretary General Abdalla Salem el-Badri also hinted a further oil
output cut. He told Iran's Energy and Oil Information Network in Tehran on Dec.
1 that "the organization is ready to cut production by another million barrel,
which is a good amount," adding that "we are all geared towards it."
The sensitive future market has been digesting the expectation of the mega
cut, which was mirrored in the recent rallies after the price touched a
four-year nadir of 40 dollars on December 5.
CAN OPEC MAKE IT?
Despite its fresh ambitions to revive the crude prices, "OPEC has not been
successful in being ahead of demand destruction, which has caused a drop in oil
prices which is starting to have an impact on non-OPEC supply," Olivier Jakob,
an oil analyst at Petromatrix, a Switzerland-based oil consultancy, told Xinhua.
The oil cartel slashed its oil output on September 10 by 520,000 bpd and
another 1.5 million bpd on October 24, but in vain. Both of them failed to forge
substantial rallies.
The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) forecast in
November that the economy of the United States, the biggest oil consumer, will
shrink by 0.9 percent next year with contraction in the first half of the year
giving way to a "languid" recovery.
Prior to the meeting, the US Federal Reserve decided Tuesday in a surprise
move to cut the benchmark interest rate to a range of zero to 0.25 percent, the
lowest level ever seen to prevent the country's ailing economy from plunging
into deep recession.
The growth rate for the 27 European Union countries in 2008 is estimated to
be only 1.4 percent, less than half of that in 2007.
The International Energy Agency (IEA) projected in a report on December 11
that oil demand in 2008 would shrink for the first time since 1983, shedding
200,000 bpd on a year-on-year basis.
The global downturn is now still unfolding itself, chorused by a series of
dire demand outlooks that haunt the traders. As a result, the market has turned
into a seesaw battle between shrinking supplies and gloomy statistics and
projections, at least in the coming few months.
"The demand for OPEC crude is projected to decline sharply in 2009, falling
1.4 million bpd to average 30.2 million bpd," OPEC said in its monthly oil
report published Tuesday, which also put the global total demand at 85.7 million
bpd.
The IEA also said in the report that the oil demand in 2009 would rebound to
86.3 million bpd, based on the hypothesis that the world economy will come to
life in the second half of the year.
"The impact of the grave global economic downturn had led to a destruction of
demand, resulting in unprecedented downward pressure being exerted on price,"
the cartel said at its meeting in Oran.
Vincent Lauerman, president of Geopolitics Central, a Canada-based energy
consultancy, said the recovery might take "several months," recommending a more
aggressive cut.
Moreover, non-OPEC producers must be taken into account. "In the United
States, the number of operating drilling rigs is dropping and projects to
develop the oil sands in Canada have been dropped one after another," said
Jakob.
According to OPEC statistics, Canada is now the biggest oil supplier for the
United States, whose production could enable traders to catch a glimpse of the
new equilibrium.
OPEC's cut was also echoed by Russia, which sent a high-ranking delegation to
the meeting and pledged a coordinated policy, but the biggest non-OPEC exporter
did not give any tangible words of output cut in Oran on Wednesday.
Khelil told the press conference after the meeting in Oran that OPEC may make
further cut in its next ministerial meeting in Marchat the headquarter in Vienna
if the 2.2 million cut can not stabilize the market.
Lauerman also hinted the possibility of further cuts if the current one turns
out to be a damp squib. "Depending on the length and depth of the global
economic slowdown, OPEC may have to cut a whole lot more."
FAIR PRICE AT HARD TIMES
It might be intriguing to define the "fair price" in the unfolding rainy
days, since the exploiting costs among the OPEC members are inevitably uneven.
A Morgan Stanley report released in early October revealed that the United
Arab Emirates' fiscal accounts would remain balanced even if oil prices were to
drop to around 25 dollars a barrel, and it would remain in surplus even at the
current prices.
According to an International Monetary Fund report, Iran, the traditional
hawk in OPEC, would suffer from deficit in current account in the near future if
the oil is priced below 75 dollars.
Saudi King Abdullah bin Abudul-Aziz told a Kuwaiti newspaper Al-Seyassah on
Nov. 29 that oil should be priced at 75 dollars a barrel, setting a benchmark
for the next round of cuts.
The king's definition of "fair price" was endorsed by experts, who downplayed
a widespread fallacy that a higher price will prolong the current global
economic downturn.
"King Abdullah's recently announced target price of US$75 per barrel is spot
on," Lauerman said.
"We do believe that the US$75 per barrel level proclaimed by the king ... is
probably the best estimate of the fair price." Jakob said, adding that the
declining price only helps the US consumers. "The world is being hurt rather
than being helped by the current oil prices."
According to a PetroMatrix report, gasoline at the US pumps was 40 percent
lower than a year ago, but consumers of other major economies still suffer from
the sticky energy prices.
In Europe, the price of diesel is only 12 percent lower than a year ago. In
China and India, the retail diesel prices are even 26percent and 9 percent
higher respectively.
DIMINISHING CLOUT OF OIL POWERS
Though a rebound of oil prices seems promising in the mid-term, the
organization's primitive approach of "Slash for Cash" is not as effective as it
was in 1980s, when the OPEC stunned the world by boosting the price from US$2.64
a barrel in 1972 to US$11.17 in 1974 and then to US$35.1 in 1981.
A dearth of unity among OPEC members marred the cartel's action and diluted
its influence on prices. A case in point is the recent Cairo meeting, where
Saudi Arabia, the most resilient producer, managed "to push the prices lower in
order to force more OPEC compliance," noted Jakob.
The oil bloc is seeking for coordinate efforts to reduce output from non-OPEC
members. Delegations from Russia, Oman, Azerbaijan and Syria also attended the
Oran meeting as observers.
"We renew our call on the non-OPEC producers and exporters to cooperate with
the Organization to support oil market stabilization," Khelil said in Oran.
Artificially keeping production low can lead to all sorts of ancillary
issues, said Conley Turner, a senior research analyst with Wall Street
Strategies, an independent market research company.
"The way things are now however provides a compelling incentive to comply,"
Turner said.
As for the popular accusations the oil powers have made towards the volatile
Western future market where the oil is priced, oil experts recommend the
producers develop a modern business approach.
"OPEC could instead use the future market to hedge more of their production
at what they see the fair price," Jakob said.