"American Idol" on Monday added a fourth face to its panel of talent
judges, a songwriter and producer who calls herself a "feisty"
"straight-shooter" looking to crown a winner who is, above all, unique.
The Grammy-nominated pop composer, Kara DioGuardi, will join veteran "Idol"
judges Simon Cowell, Paula Abdul and Randy Jackson for the upcoming eighth
season of U.S. television's most watched show when it returns in January 2009.
The addition of DioGuardi, 37, marks the biggest format change for the
series, subtitled "The Search for a Superstar," since it burst into prime time
on the Fox network in 2002.
Self-assured with a matter-of-fact, no-nonsense style, DioGuardi is expected
to provide a counterweight to the sometimes gushy, even vacuous on-air persona
of Abdul, 46, who first gained fame in the 1980s as a pop singer.
Though hardly a household name, DioGuardi has written and produced songs for
numerous recording artists, including pop stars Gwen Stefani and Christina
Aguilera as well as past "Idol" winners Carrie Underwood and Kelly Clarkson, and
has received several awards in recent years.
In a conference call with reporters, she noted a previous collaboration with
Abdul, saying they co-wrote a song early in her career, "Spinning Around," that
went on to become a hit for Kylie Minogue.
"For the past seven seasons, Paula has had to endure the experience of being
the only woman at the judges table," said Mike Darnell, head of alternative
programming at Fox. "With Kara by her side, Paula finally has some back-up, and
now there is going to be a lot more 'girl power' on the show."
Producers will put that chemistry to its first test on Tuesday, when
DioGuardi joins Abdul, Cowell and Jackson for the kickoff of auditions in New
York.
DioGuardi declined to critique her soon-to-be peers but said she finds
Cowell, known for giving the most unvarnished appraisals among the panelists, to
be generally fair. "I think Simon is pretty spot on most of the time," she said.
The record producer and talent scout described herself as "pretty feisty" and
willing to stand up for her opinions.
"I'm going to be a straight-shooter," she said. "I'm just somebody who's
really honest and gives my opinion, and if I feel the need to be hard with
someone in order to get that across, I will be. And if I feel I need to be
softer and more nurturing with some of the contestants, I'll be that."
The most important quality she is looking for in singers, aside from a "great
voice," is a style that sets them apart.
"It's not about vocal acrobatics. It's about being unique and doing things
that are identifiable to you," she said. "What makes an artist is ... when their
song comes on the radio, I know exactly who it is."
She said her favorite song is John Lennon's "Imagine," a tune that figured
prominently in the show last season as the signature performance of young
crooner David Archuleta, who was narrowly defeated by rocker David Cook in the
end.
The show averaged 28.1 million viewers weekly last season, compared to 30.8
million at the height of its popularity in 2006. But the finale in May between
Cook and Archuleta drew some 32 million viewers, up 3 percent from a year
earlier.
Although "Idol" has featured a three-judge panel since its inception, the
program was originally conceived as having four panelists, said executive
producer Cecile Frot-Coutaz.
Producers hired hip-hop radio personality Angie Martinez as a fourth member
of the team for the second season, but she quit after judging a few auditions
because she felt bad about having to reject some contestants and never appeared
on the show.
Including the original British version, "Pop Idol," all had four judges.
DioGuardi is not a complete newcomer to TV talent shows, having served as a
judge herself for ABC's short-lived, singing contest, "The One: Making a Music
Star."