Shanghai Daily news
It had been a topic of such intense speculation, and for so long, that when
China did finally raise interest rates, the move was something of an
anti-climax.
The central bank's decision last week to raise the benchmark
one-year lending rate by 27 basis points to 5.58 percent "will have as much
impact on the Chinese economy, as putting a bicycle in front of a speeding
locomotive," said researchers Bob Prince and Jason Rotenberg of Bridgewater
Associates, a Westport, Connecticut-based money manager.
How will a tiny
increase in interest rates curb overheating when draconian measures to cut bank
lending to aluminum, auto, cement, steel and real-estate companies have had only
a limited impact on the economy since they were introduced in
April?
Fixed-asset investments in China increased 28 percent from a year
earlier in September. The deceleration in the economy - gross domestic product
grew 9.1 percent in the third quarter, down from 9.6 percent in the previous
three months - was merely due to a statistical base effect, according to Dong
Tao, an economist at Credit Suisse First Boston in Hong Kong.
It is unlikely
to put the inflation genie back into the bottle with a token increase in rates,
when consumer prices have been rising close to a seven-year high of 5.3 percent
for four months.
Still, the interest-rate decision isn't without its
significance. To six strategists surveyed, the rate move came as a signal that
the Chinese currency will be allowed to trade more freely by the end of next
year.
The clue lies in what the central bank can - or can't - do next. One
argument is that now that the political debate on the merits of raising interest
rates has been resolved, the central bank, which last increased rates nine years
ago, will make bigger increases.
That won't be easy. If the Chinese interest
rates rise too much too fast, more foreign capital will flow into China. The
central bank will have to buy the incoming dollars to maintain its "managed
floating" mechanism, adding more liquidity in the banking system.
"A flexible
exchange rate is needed," says Lehman Brothers economist Rob Subbaraman, "in
order to have policy independence in moving interest rates."
Government
controls on money coming into the country and leaving it aren't nearly as strict
as they need to be for China to avoid facing up to the reality of "impossible
trinity," an economic principle that says no country can simultaneously keep its
exchange rate fixed, its monetary policy independent and its capital markets
open to the world.
"China is excessively cheap and highly productive," said
Bridgewater's Prince and Rotenberg. "The problem will eventually be rectified by
a substantial exchange rate adjustment."
(The author is a Bloomberg columnist. The views expressed
are his own.)