No fast bite from realty profits tax
10/3/2005 14:29
Shanghai Daily news
Shanghai's latest effort to cool its booming property market - a 5.5 percent
tax on short-term profits - is unlikely to significantly slow the spike in
housing prices, according to analysts and the latest data from a major real
estate index. Because the new policy was imposed on a limited segment of the
market, its influence will be narrow, said analysts including Li Zhenyu, who
works for Coldwell Banker Sincere Real Estate Co. Attempting to prevent a
speculative bubble in the real estate sector, the city announced on Sunday the
imposition of a 5.5 percent tax on residents who sell their apartments within
the first year after purchase. "As the housing market in Shanghai is huge,
the new rules will not drag down the overall prices in the city," Li
said. The city's Website for second-hand home and apartment transactions
reported that average sales prices slid slightly after the tax was announced but
went on to recover. The average sales price listed by the Shanghai Real
Estate Guide fell from 9,377 yuan (US$1,133) per square meter on Friday to 8,987
yuan on Tuesday but rebounded to 9,717 yuan yesterday. "In the current
red-hot property market, some people may simply pass along any higher costs for
selling their houses to the buyers," said Lina Wong, managing director of East
China, Colliers International, a leading international real estate firm. "The
new policy will influence only the bargain hunters in the property market," said
Wong. By setting the one-year period, it distinguishes long-term investors
from short-term speculators and even may create a healthier environment for
long-term growth, Colliers said in a report. Developers seeking to exploit
Shanghai's surging market also see the new tax policy as a potential
plus. "As a land developer, we appreciate sustainable development in
the real estate market over the long run," said Fan Wei, of Shanghai Forte Land
Co. Meanwhile, Shanghai is hoping it won't suffer a repeat of what happened
when Hangzhou, in neighboring Zhejiang Province, imposed a 20 percent real
estate profits tax last year to curb speculation. The city eventually decided to
rescind the tax after sellers simply transferred it to buyers and aggravated the
runup in property market. But the tax was removed later last year as house
sellers transferred the tax to buyers, which further stimulated the housing
price to go higher in the capital city of Zhejiang Province.
|