Lessons from the disgrace of a pollution campaigner
27/12/2005 11:17
Xu Qin/Shanghai Daily news
For Xie Zhenhua, the fall
from national hero to disgraced official came overnight. For 12 years, he had
been a much-admired crusader against pollution. But on December 2, he had to
step down because of dereliction of duty. Yes, he had ordered the closure of
many plants polluting the nation's rivers and lakes, often in the face of
entrenched local protectionism. Yes, he had turned the country's
environmental watchdog from being a "toothless" nonentity into a giant that
could bite hard. As the former head of the State Environmental Protection
Administration, Xie was by no means a "rubber stamp" official. In 2003, UN
Secretary-General Kofi Annan awarded him the Sasakawa Environment Prize for that
year, citing his great zeal and imagination in promoting sustainable growth in
China. However, this long-time campaigner in the cause of improving China's
environmental health on November 13 missed the precious chance to stop major
pollution in a river in Northeast China from worsening. And that proved to
be his water-loo. On that day, a blast at a chemical plant on the Songhua
River caused severe pollution. As a result, the city of Harbin had to suspend
its tap water supply for four days leaving hundreds of thousands of people high
and dry. Had Xie acted earlier and done his due diligence, the pollution
spill could have been tackled in a more timely manner to say the
least. Indeed, although his words and actions had been praiseworthy in the
past, he was slow to act in this case. From November 14 to November 17, when
toxic chemicals contaminated the river and human life was at risk, no reports
were received from Jilin's provincial authorities and this revealed an obvious
lack of emergency reaction on the part of the local government. Xie failed to
detect the deliberate concealment and thus lost his best opportunity to act
promptly. His carelessness, or his blind trust in local reports, cost him,
and the health of the river, dearly. The poisonous slick finally passed the
city on December 4 and made its way slowly through Heilongjiang Province toward
the Russian border despite the freezing weather. The approach of the pollution
also rang alarm bells in Russia. The administration "as the main body for
environmental protection did not pay enough attention and fell short in its
evaluation of the possible severe results arising from the incident. Thus, it
holds the responsibility for the losses," said China Central Television. To
blame everything on Xie in the case of the Songhua River pollution might be
unfair to him. But his resignation shows the sincerity of the central
government in disciplining whoever is responsible in one way or another, even a
high-ranking official - because the issues at stake are too high. The signal
of the central government is clear: No one shall be allowed to overlook the
gravity of a pollution incident for even a second. The job of an environment
watchdog is around the clock. Anyone in that position must be vigilant all the
time, not daring to close his or her eyes and ears for an instant. The
anti-pollution campaign needs more than fine words or short-term actions. It
needs lifelong devotion. To be sure, Xie's resignation alone won't
automatically put an end to pollution. But if we look at Xie's rise and fall
from a different angle, he might not be such a tragic character after all. In
fact, both his glorious past and a sudden fall have allowed us to see a man of
conscience and social responsibility. When he did well, he deserved
accolades. When he failed, he admitted generously that he was to
blame. Pollution will take generations to be fixed. The one and most
important issue in that cause is conscience, a sense of responsibility and the
courage to admit errors and to quit. Xie is actually an amiable and
easy-going person. Many journalists like to call him "Lao Xie," meaning "Old
Xie," a name that is usually used among peers or good friends. You seldom
see this kind of appellation in officialdom, as many Chinese officials like to
be called by their glossy titles, such as "Minister This" and "Minister
That." No one is perfect and not everyone has Xie's courage to quit.
Otherwise not only pollution but all the safety problems as we see in one
mine blast after another would have been tackled more
efficiently.
|