Mine tragedies can be stopped
3/12/2004 10:26
Shanghai Daily news
It took Ma Changsheng more than 20 minutes to travel 1,000 meters. Inhaling
toxic gas and unable to see through thick smoke, he stumbled and crawled his way
out of an underground mine passage. Ma was one of the 127 lucky miners who
escaped the massive gas explosion at Chenjiashan Coal Mine in Shaanxi Province
on Sunday morning. Another 166 miners were not so fortunate. The victims were
officially declared dead after being trapped in an environment with a high
density of coal, gas and carbon monoxide for three days. The blast could be
the country's worst mining accident since an explosion in southern Guizhou
Province killed 162 people four years ago. The coal mine industry, which
provides the bulk of fuel for the world's seventh-biggest economy, has a dismal
safety record underscored by a series of major accidents this year. Last
month a gas explosion at Daping Coal Mine in Henan Province killed 148 miners.
Earlier this month, another explosion, also in Henan, destroyed 33
lives. Xinhua said on Tuesday that the death rate for every 100 tons of coal
produced in China was 100 times higher than the United States. According to
the latest figures released by the State Administration of Work Safety, there
were 4,153 coal mine deaths in the first nine months of this year, 630 less than
last year during the same period, but still alarmingly high. The Chenjiashan
blast was avoidable though. The state-owned coal mine was a problem waiting to
happen. Its high density of gas due to the mixed growth of coal, oil and gas, as
well as its coal bed has been a fire hazard for years. As a result, a fire
breaks out at the mine every three to six months on average and the shortest gap
between two fires was 24 days. Six days before Sunday's explosion, a fire
broke out at the mine. By then the mine had already produced 2 million tons of
coal this year, exceeding its annual capacity by 200,00 tons. But eager to boost
production, officials chose not to close the mine. They simply told miners to
work in another shaft. They even threatened to fine or suspend miners who
refused to go back to work due to safety concerns, according to China Youth
Daily. If mine managers made a different decision then, or invested more in
safety three years earlier - when a different blast killed 38 - the tragedy
would have been prevented. Premier Wen Jiabao said in the past that the
government must "seriously get to the root of who is responsible." But finding
out all the details of the disaster is not enough. The man held responsible for
the accident three years ago was removed from his post only to be appointed head
of another mine six months later. The government must carry out punishment to
the letter. And that power should be centralized, at least at the provincial
level. It's too naive to trust a county magistrate, who is too often consumed
with boosting local gross domestic product, to really punish private
contractors. The lust for money - at the expense of lives - should be curbed
not just by legal punishment, but also by heavy fines. Taking their profits
would teach them once and for all.
|