With China showing positive view on the shutdown of the Yongbyon reactor
last Saturday and Six-Party Talks negotiators set to meet again in Beijing
today, observers are wondering to what extent the initial actions on Korean
Peninsula denuclearization have been implemented.
Prevailing view among experts holds that the "initial actions for the
implementation of the joint statement", or Feb. 13 agreement, a significant step
for the talks, have been implemented "step by step with endeavors from all
parties", but an all-around implementation "still needs time".
Negotiators signed the initial actions during the fifth round of Six-Party
Talks on Feb. 13. The nuclear issue started to record remarkable progress after
six countries -- the Democratic People's Republic of Korea (DPRK), the Republic
of Korea, China, the United States, Japan and Russia -- started negotiations in
Aug. 2003.
"Generally, carrying out the initial actions is not a big headache. Five
months passed, all parties, working very hard, hope to implement them as soon as
possible," said Shi Yinhong, professor with the college of international
relations under the elite Renmin University of China.
All parties concerned have agreed to implement the Sept. 2005 Joint Statement
in a phased manner in line with the principle of "action for action", says the
Feb. 13 agreement.
They agreed to take actions simultaneously in the initial phase, including
the eventual abandonment of the DPRK's Yongbyon nuclear facilities, provision of
economic, energy and humanitarian assistance to the DPRK and the establishment
of a peace and stability mechanism on the Korean Peninsula.
REACTOR SHUTDOWN
With a South Korean ship carrying 6,200 tons of heavy fuel oil arriving at
DPRK's northeastern port of Songbong last Saturday, DPRK announced its shutdown
of the Yongbyon reactor, a widely regarded substantial step, after a 10-member
team of UN inspectors arrived in the capital Pyongyang to verify and monitor the
reactor sealing.
Positive reactions on the nuclear shutdown pushed the upcoming round of
Six-Party Talks onto a favorable stage.
The Feb. 13 agreement says DPRK must declare all nuclear programs and disable
all existing nuclear facilities, including graphite-moderated reactors and its
post-treatment plant, and other parties must provide a total of 1 million tons
of heavy fueloil or equivalent aid, with the initial shipment of 50,000 tons.
Tao Wenzhao, a research fellow with the American Research Institute of the
Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, said the current shutdown of nuclear
facilities is a "reversible" action, which means the facilities can be reopened
at any time.
"Only after complete denuclearization can facilities become really dead,"
said Tao.
BARRIER AHEAD
Experts believe technical problems still remain, such as dealing with nuclear
facilities outside the Yongbyon reactor, DPRK's leading nuclear research center,
and the fact that most assistance promise has yet to be materialized.
As main negotiators, the DPRK and the United States should start bilateral
talks aimed at resolving pending bilateral issues and moving toward full
diplomatic relations.
The US will start removing the designation of the DPRK as a state- sponsor of
terrorism and terminating the Trading with the Enemy Act concerning DPRK, says
the agreement.
The DPRK and Japan will start bilateral talks aiming to normalize their
relations in line with the Pyongyang Declaration, based on settling "unfortunate
past" and "issues of concern", the document says.
Working groups over five subjects enshrined in the agreement have already
been initiated, covering a wide range of issues such as a nuclear-free Korean
Peninsula, normalization of relations among countries involved, establishment of
a peace and security mechanism in Northeast Asia and economic and energy
cooperation among countries concerned.
However, analysts pointed out that the inauguration of working groups does
not mean the start of a normal operation. The upcoming talks will discuss how to
push forward the agenda of the five working groups, observers predicted.
"Since verification and denuclearization involve many technical issues,
pushing ahead the DPRK nuclear issue requires patience of all parties," said
Tao, the researcher.