China's top health authorities yesterday verified that the first
laboratory-confirmed death from bird flu on the Chinese mainland occurred in
late 2003 rather than 2005, which was the original starting point of China's
H5N1 fatality timeline.
This November 2003 case is two full years before the October 2005 case in
Hunan Province, in which a 9-year-old boy had incorrectly been identified as the
Chinese mainland's first confirmed case.
The 24-year-old Beijing man who contracted bird flu three years ago died
during the outbreak of severe acute respiratory syndrome (SARS). At that time,
the man was diagnosed with serious pneumonia without clear a cause. Because
testing at that time showed he had not died of SARS, experts kept his sample for
further research.
In 2004, when a human case of bird flu was reported in Viet Nam, Chinese
scientists began to suspect that the young man who had served in the army had
died of bird flu in 2003, according to source from Ministry of Health (MOH).
H5N1 was isolated from the sample.
"So far, the source of infection still remains unknown," said Mao Qun'an,
spokesman of MOH. "But this confirmation offers important clues for studying the
bird flu outbreak."
There has been no cause of infection determined for the November 2003 case.
The man was a soldier in the PLA, based in Beijing. He did not travel for at
least two weeks prior to his illness. It is unknown whether or not he was
exposed to any sick poultry or other animals prior to his infection.
There were no outbreaks of H5N1 reported in the Beijing area at the time,
according to MOH report submitted to World Health Organization.
Many thought that "many other countries had human cases beginning in late
2003 and early 2004, but not China," said Roy Wadia, spokesman for the Beijing
Office of WHO.
"This case now means that China has the first human case in the current H5N1
cycle, which began in late 2003."
"The case in November 2003 shows us once again that whenever H5N1 virus is in
the environment, it is possible for humans to get infected and humans do get
infected," Wadia said. "It shows us that H5N1 has been in the environment on the
Chinese mainland for quite some time now."
China first reported a H5N1 outbreak in poultry in late January 2004. By now,
the country has reported 20 human infections and 13 fatalities, including the
November 2003 case.
"This latest scientific findings reminds China to improve its disease
reporting mechanisms by including the scientific and research institutions in
the system," Mao Qun'an said.
The problem is that most of China's human cases have not had a conclusive
source of infection, according to Wadia. This is because human cases are found
first, without any warning of animal outbreaks in the area.
Agriculture and animal health authorities have had difficulty finding animal
H5N1 cases in China, especially if the animals die sporadically in small groups,
Wadia said.
The surveillance and reporting systems for both animal and human health need
to be strengthened, he added.